Kinyi explored how to handle negative comments on social media. Here, I would like to add practical advice on responding to a poor product review.
A company that brings a product to market may receive a negative review sooner or later. That is not necessarily a bad thing: feedback can reveal opportunities to improve. But how should you respond, and what if you consider the criticism unfair?
When the criticism is justified
Imagine a journalist or blogger testing a new speaker and finding that one of its drivers crackles at higher volume. The resulting review criticises the product.
Contact the reviewer promptly and ask for more information. At the same time, investigate whether this is an isolated fault or a wider issue. Speed and honesty are important. Rather than becoming defensive, help the journalist understand what happened.
If the fault is limited to the review sample, offer a replacement for testing. If it is a broader problem, inform affected customers, apologise sincerely and explain what you are doing to resolve it. Proactive, personal communication shows that you understand the issue and are taking action.
When you disagree with the findings
What if you believe the criticism is not supported by the test? For example, a consumer publication may compare several speakers using a benchmark that does not suit your product’s intended use.
A personal, constructive approach still matters. Contact the journalist and offer a discussion. Prepare carefully: explain the concern with the benchmark and provide evidence rather than simply objecting to the verdict.
Keep expectations realistic. A discussion does not guarantee a new review or a changed rating. The goal is to understand the testing approach, explain relevant context and give the reviewer accurate information to consider.
Journalists want to inform their readers. Respect their independence even when you disagree.
Use criticism as an opportunity to improve
Negative reviews are uncomfortable, but they can open a useful conversation with the reviewer. Whether you accept or dispute the criticism, use it as a reason to investigate, learn and improve.
Explore how we support product reviews and media relationships.
Steven
More news ›